Information Technology Management · Ch. 2

Strategy & Technology

Sustainable competitive advantage, Porter's Five Forces, the Value Chain, and industry structure — McCombs School of Business, UT Austin

5 Porter's Forces: Rivalry · New Entrants · Substitutes · Suppliers · Buyers
CA Sustainable Competitive Advantage: Outperforming peers consistently
15 Minutes: Southwest Airlines' famous turnaround time at the gate
8 Ways to create CA: Lock-in, Differentiation, Barriers, etc.
01
Core Concepts Strategy Fundamentals
Sustainable Competitive Advantage (CA)
The ability of a firm to consistently outperform its industry peers over a long period. Achieving CA requires establishing a unique difference that can be preserved against competitor imitation. [cite: 9]
Porter, Competitive Advantage
Competitive Strategy
Deliberately choosing a different set of activities to deliver a unique mix of value. Strategy is about being different, not just doing the same things better. [cite: 10]
Porter, "What is Strategy?"
Operational Effectiveness
Performing similar activities better than rivals. While important, it is usually not enough for sustainable CA because rivals can quickly copy "best practices." [cite: 10]
Porter, HBR 1996
Switching Costs
The costs a consumer incurs when moving from one product to another. These can be monetary (fees), time-based (learning a new UI), or effort-based (moving data). [cite: 18]
Gallaugher, Ch. 2
Network Effects
When the value of a product or service increases as its number of users grows. Examples include eBay and social media platforms. [cite: 18]
Gallaugher, Ch. 2
Barriers to Entry
Factors that make it difficult for new firms to enter an industry. High barriers lead to a low threat of new entrants and more likely sustainable profits. [cite: 14]
Porter's Five Forces Model
02
Industry Analysis Porter's Five Forces

The External View: Positioning Within the Industry

01

Porter’s Five Forces model is focused externally, describing how a firm is positioned within its industry. It evaluates: (1) Rivalry among existing competitors, (2) Threat of new entrants, (3) Threat of substitutions, (4) Bargaining power of suppliers, and (5) Bargaining power of buyers. [cite: 13]

Industry structure profoundly influences strategy. For example, the personal computer industry is notoriously "tough" due to intense rivalry and high supplier/buyer power, leading to low profitability for most. However, firms like Apple reconcile this by building ecosystems that lock in customers. [cite: 19, 20]

Strategic Insight: An industry with HIGH barriers to entry has a LOW threat of new entrants. For example, starting a professional football team has a massive capital barrier compared to starting a food truck. [cite: 13, 14]

The Internal View: The Value Chain Model

02

The Value Chain is the set of activities through which a product or service is created and delivered to customers. It is split into Primary Functions (revenue drivers like Logistics, Operations, Marketing) and Support Functions (cost centers like HR, R&D, Procurement). [cite: 24, 25]

Sustainable CA is often created by linking components of the value chain in unique ways. In Apple's case, the "Genius Bar" staff at the Apple Store represent the "Service" primary function, providing a key touchpoint that differentiates the brand from competitors. [cite: 25]

Key Distinction: Primary functions "touch" the product or service, while support functions provide the infrastructure to allow primary functions to happen. [cite: 25]
03
Barriers to Entry Protecting the Moat
Barrier Type Definition / Mechanism Example
Capital Intensity How much money is required to start the business. [cite: 14] Building a semiconductor fab or a football stadium.
Switching Costs Time, effort, or money needed for a customer to move to a rival. [cite: 18] Moving from Windows to Mac (learning curve).
Network Effects Value increases as more users join the network. [cite: 18] eBay (more buyers attract more sellers).
Distribution Channels The difficulty of getting the product to the final customer. [cite: 15] Shelf space at Walmart or access to an app store.
Regulation Legal hurdles, patents, and intellectual property. [cite: 15] FDA approval for a new life-saving drug.

Source: MCCombs Strategy Slides, based on Michael Porter's Frameworks. [cite: 13, 14, 15]

04
Knowledge Check Are you a strategist?
Unit 02 Assessment Strategy Quiz
1

According to Michael Porter, how can a company outperform its rivals?

2

Which of these is considered a "Primary Function" in the Value Chain?